The Smart Aleck's Guide to American History by Adam Selzer
Were you
aware that George Washington was well known for crying like a little girl in
public? Or that Ben Franklin used to take so-called “air baths” as an excuse to
wander around the house naked? I don’t know about you, but I don’t remember
learning these little factoids about our nation’s founding fathers in my history
class! The Smart Aleck’s Guide to American History, written by Adam Selzer and staff, presents our country’s history from the
earliest American settlers to the election of President Obama in a sassy and sarcastic,
yet informative way. This history guide leaves the typical spewing
names of battles and dates in the dust.
Reading the Smart Aleck’s Guide felt as if I was talking to a friend—the one
loudmouth that says any and everything…kind of obnoxious, but being funny
enough that you can overlook that. The basis of the book is factual history,
written with a witty twist including oddball footnotes (i.e. “The sailors on
the Mayflower called the Pilgrims
“glib-glabbety puke stockings”. Yes, the word “puke”, along with most of the
swearwords people use today, had been in common use for centuries then.”) and
big pictures with snarky captions (under a picture of Civil War soldier donning
similar white beards: “Either a 1917 reunion of Civil War soldiers in Washington,
D.C., or a Colonel Sanders look-alike contest”.).
Also in the book, small recurring blurbs can be found throughout such as
“Stupid Hats of History” (complete with photos, of course) and “Great Myths of
History”, debunking many commonly-taught historical falsehoods. At the end of
each chapter, there are vocab words, a section titled “Some of the Stuff We
Missed” and amusing essay questions such as “What are some good ways to defend
yourself against Civil War reenactors who disagree with your interpretation of
the war?” or “Who was a bigger jerk, Hitler or Stalin?”.
Teachers beware if
assigning this book, as its stated purpose to the reader is to “throw your
teachers off-balance for entire class periods” and “identify their lies and
half-truths!”. What else could you expect though from a self-proclaimed smart aleck? It’s all part of the theme. In all honestly, I found this book extremely
entertaining, offering historical knowledge in a way I’ve never experienced
before…sarcastic, witty, sometimes rude, but chockfull of genuine information.
For any kid (or adult) who doesn’t respond to the typical teaching format of
history or for any reluctant readers, this book could be a fantastic
opportunity for them to be engaged while learning a ton of our country’s history
(and getting major laughs out of it too).
Hi Sarah! I love the way you described this book! Your tone made this story seem so inviting. Plus, the fact that you said reading it seemed as if you were talking to a friend just is so appealing, as sarcastic and witty is how me and my friends are. I think that this type of writing could really intrigue students and could perhaps get them interested in history and reading; they may want to find out more about one aspect of history because they read it in this book.
This novel sounds very interesting and looks like an immensely entertaining read, however, I consider it to be definite hazard for jr./high school students because they might engage with the "bad" information instead. To me, these students would learn and memorize that in placement of the information they are suppose to learn for class. This is not the first time I have encountered a book that unveils the hidden truths of historical people. In my second year of college I read the novel, Secret Lives of Great Artists by Elizabeth Lunday. Like I stated before, I read this novel in college and likewise, we talked about both sides of the information, however, most importantly we used the information of their achievements instead of the "gossip". Nevertheless, this book was not nominated as "one of the best in class resources to learn from", but for reluctant readers. I definitely consider that any reluctant reader can pick this novel up and learn from it while reading :)
As a history major, I can firmly say that some history lessons can be dry and boring. This book sounds like it is the complete opposite of a uninteresting litany of dates and important names! Though it made it onto a YA list, I think this book could appeal to anyone from about 4th grade and up; both adults and children will most likely enjoy the sarcastically funny facts. I know I love learning factoid trivia, especially when its funny. As a fellow smart aleck, this book has my name written all over it!
Sarah, your review really makes me want to read this book! I am not the biggest history fan and I think engaging in a book of this sort would make learning about the facts more interesting and I'd probably remember the information better. I could see how some students who were younger or less mature might not see beyond the sarcasm or use the information other than it is intended but as you mention, I think this could be a great alternative for reluctant readers, to show them that reading (and learning) can be fun or to those who don't respond well to the typical teaching format.
Click here to read a basic description of what is required in each of your postings to this blog.
Visit this website to view a rubric for your writing on Book Wind.
Watch this video to see a demonstration of how to write and publish to the Book Wind blog.
Watch this video to see a demonstration of how to edit and comment upon book reviews published to the Book Wind blog.
Visit some of the blogs and websites below to orient yourself to the tone and style of writing reviews of literature on the web.
Click here to see a model post that I wrote for my own blog not too long ago, and click here and here and here to see examples of high quality blog postings by other authors. Note the strong voice, hyperlinks, pictures, and sometimes even video embedded in these posts.
To start posting to this blog, click on the "New Post" link at the top of the screen when you are signed into Book Wind, or click on "New Post" within your Blogger Dashboard. Click here to learn more about the Blogger post editor. Please note that if you click on "save" within the post editor, Blogger will save, but not publish, your writing. Click on "publish" to make your writing visible to all.
Click here to get more advice about posting to blogs. In general, the advice here is very sound, although I would say that 250-500 words (about 1/2 to 1 full print page) is the appropriate length in this context.
5 comments:
Glad you liked it! Our first Shakespeare guide rolled this week, with many more to come! Smart Aleck's Guide
Hi Sarah! I love the way you described this book! Your tone made this story seem so inviting. Plus, the fact that you said reading it seemed as if you were talking to a friend just is so appealing, as sarcastic and witty is how me and my friends are. I think that this type of writing could really intrigue students and could perhaps get them interested in history and reading; they may want to find out more about one aspect of history because they read it in this book.
This novel sounds very interesting and looks like an immensely entertaining read, however, I consider it to be definite hazard for jr./high school students because they might engage with the "bad" information instead. To me, these students would learn and memorize that in placement of the information they are suppose to learn for class. This is not the first time I have encountered a book that unveils the hidden truths of historical people. In my second year of college I read the novel, Secret Lives of Great Artists by Elizabeth Lunday. Like I stated before, I read this novel in college and likewise, we talked about both sides of the information, however, most importantly we used the information of their achievements instead of the "gossip". Nevertheless, this book was not nominated as "one of the best in class resources to learn from", but for reluctant readers. I definitely consider that any reluctant reader can pick this novel up and learn from it while reading :)
As a history major, I can firmly say that some history lessons can be dry and boring. This book sounds like it is the complete opposite of a uninteresting litany of dates and important names! Though it made it onto a YA list, I think this book could appeal to anyone from about 4th grade and up; both adults and children will most likely enjoy the sarcastically funny facts. I know I love learning factoid trivia, especially when its funny. As a fellow smart aleck, this book has my name written all over it!
Sarah, your review really makes me want to read this book! I am not the biggest history fan and I think engaging in a book of this sort would make learning about the facts more interesting and I'd probably remember the information better. I could see how some students who were younger or less mature might not see beyond the sarcasm or use the information other than it is intended but as you mention, I think this could be a great alternative for reluctant readers, to show them that reading (and learning) can be fun or to those who don't respond well to the typical teaching format.
Post a Comment